From the Reading Chair

Articles by Laurel Cohn

Scene vs Summary: A version of ‘show, don’t tell’

Date: 19 November 2026
Guest blog by team editor Bronwyn Birdsall

Show, don’t tell. It’s a line repeated in workshops, scribbled in margins, and cited as fundamental craft wisdom – with good reason. By using sensory details, action, dialogue and internal thoughts, readers are let into the inner world of characters and prompted to infer emotions and events, rather than have them explicitly stated. However, in my own writing and in mentoring others, I’ve found this guidance, while sound, overlooks a crucial consideration: sometimes telling is the better choice.

Scene vs Summary: A version of ‘show, don’t tell’

Date: 19 November 2026
Guest blog by team editor Bronwyn Birdsall

Show, don’t tell. It’s a line repeated in workshops, scribbled in margins, and cited as fundamental craft wisdom – with good reason. By using sensory details, action, dialogue and internal thoughts, readers are let into the inner world of characters and prompted to infer emotions and events, rather than have them explicitly stated. However, in my own writing and in mentoring others, I’ve found this guidance, while sound, overlooks a crucial consideration: sometimes telling is the better choice.

Another way of thinking about ‘show, don’t tell’ is to consider the relationship between scene and summary; scenes are aligned with ‘showing’ and summary is aligned with ‘telling’. Both scenes and summaries are needed for effective storytelling. The trick is to figure out what your story needs in each moment – and this is as true for memoir and narrative non-fiction as it is for fiction.

 

What are scenes?

Scenes are moments that unfold in real-time. The reader is taken into a specific moment of time and a specific place as the characters move across the setting and interact with others.

Scenes are ‘shown’ more than they are ‘told’ to readers. That means the reader is in the character’s perspective, and the reader senses and experiences the moment with them.

Scenes immerse a reader in a story. Use a scene for the most dramatic parts of your story, key plot points – anything the narrative has been building towards. For example, in a spy novel, imagine the main character is meeting up with an informant on a crowded city street. The story has been building to this risky moment. Their whispered conversation, shadowed by potential danger, would likely work best as a scene, unfolding in real-time so readers can experience the high-stakes moment.

During the editing process of my novel, Time and Tide in Sarajevo (Affirm Press, 2022), my editor pointed out that a key revelatory moment was skipped over. I had ended the chapter right before the main character reveals a secret (in what I felt was a cliffhanger), and the opening of the following chapter had everyone’s reactions. The narrative had been building to this moment, and for it to be as effective as possible, we needed to see the main character tell the secret in real time. Once I wrote the scene, not only was the dramatic impact stronger, but I could see it was a crucial moment for the reader to connect with the character’s growth.

 

What is summary?

Summaries, on the other hand, do not happen in real-time. Summaries convey character history, sociopolitical context, ideas, concepts and information rather than creating a specific experience that a character (and by extension, the reader) is living through.

Summaries can cover any period of time, from a day, a month, to a year or beyond. They relay events within a small section of text. Because of this, summaries are often ‘told’ more than ‘shown’ to readers. Summaries allow you to guide the reader to different locations or convey something from a different time.

Use a summary when readers need to know that something happened, but it’s not important for them to experience it happening, moment by moment. For instance, the character in the spy novel might have had a terrible night’s sleep, but the reader doesn’t need to experience each moment they tossed and turned. A sentence indicating it as they await their informant will be as effective.

 

Finding the balance

The balance between scene and summary affects the pacing of your story. In manuscripts I assess, I often find that writers have clustered too many scenes together, which can exhaust readers, or have relied too heavily on summary, distancing the reader from the characters and their world. The key is making choices about what gets the full dramatic treatment of a scene and what can be efficiently handled through summary. It is important to note that summary carries equal narrative weight to scenes and can reveal character insights that emerge more clearly through the long view of events it provides.

A writer I mentor recently faced a conundrum: she wanted to cover several months of a character’s life, conveying how they changed in that time and their sensory experiences in a new environment. After some experimentation, she landed on an effective balance where she shifted between the character’s experiences in summary (the long view) and scene (precise, evocative moments). As I read her latest draft, I was completely carried along her character’s emotional journey.

 

No strict rules

There are no absolute rules when it comes to writing. Sometimes you’ll make a choice that defies logic, yet on the page it just works. That’s part of the art of storytelling – instinct can outdo instruction. Still, it helps to be aware of the common traps that writers fall into with scene and summary, so that when you break the ‘rules,’ you’re doing so purposefully.

A few patterns to watch out for:

  • Scenes doing the wrong job. A scene might be given full dramatic treatment when the material doesn’t warrant it — for instance, two characters spending a page debating what film to watch, while the turning point of their relationship is brushed past in a single line of summary. Ask yourself if you’re spotlighting the right moments.
  • Summaries that tell but don’t interpret. The most effective summaries don’t just compress time, they also reveal perspective: how the character interprets what happened, or how their view has shifted. Or, if the summary covers sociopolitical context or ideas and concepts, the perspective will provide the reader with a framework for the story as it unfolds.
  • Dialogue as hidden summary. Sometimes writers slip in summary under the guise of dialogue, such as a character rattling off ‘As you know, we’ve been living here three months and…’ This looks like scene, but it functions as exposition. Spotting when dialogue is carrying the weight of summary can help you decide if it’s the right vehicle.

 

Practical exercises

Pick up a novel or memoir you’ve enjoyed. Take note of what is scene and what is summary: look at how dialogue, real-time experiences of the characters and atmosphere bring a story alive to a reader. See how the use of summary has conveyed efficiently what a reader needs to know, and how the writer has found a balance between the two.

Now turn to your own work in progress and do the same exercise: highlight what is scene and what is summary. Consider whether there are any sections that would be more appropriately shifted to either scene or summary.

This is a great exercise for a fresh perspective on your writing – especially if you’ve read it over and over, and can sense something isn’t working, but can’t quite land on why.

 

Finding your story’s rhythm

Like many aspects of craft, finding the right balance between scene and summary is less about rules and more about rhythm. You’ll discover, draft by draft, where you need to slow the story down and let the reader live in the moment, and where you need to pull back for a broader sweep. Over time, you’ll develop an instinct for when to linger and when to leap. Adjusting the balance is a way of finding the story’s rhythm until it feels true.

There’s no single formula that works for every writer or every project. The real practice is learning to trust yourself to make deliberate choices rather than default ones, and to experiment until you find what clicks. When you do, you’ll discover that your story holds readers not just through what happens, but through how you’ve chosen to let it unfold.

 

See also The Role of Summary

You might also enjoy...

Ready to work with an expert on your project?

Got a
Question?